Listen to the Article: Strategies for Brokers to Counter CFD Scams & Minimize Harm

​

In recent times, due to the rapid growth of the financial market and the acceleration of globalization, an increasing number of forex brokers have begun to offer contracts for difference (CFD) trading. In fact, CFD trading has been widely accepted by mainstream financial markets for over 20 years. Today, Fazzaco will discuss with you the reasons why CFD trading has become increasingly popular among brokers and the essential strategies to be implemented to avoid risks and scams associated with CFDs.

More Brokers Are Expanding Their CFD Brokerage Offerings

Since the second half of 2022, Fazzaco has reported multiple instances of multi-asset brokers either entering or expanding CFD brokerage. For example, ActivTrades, a leading FX broker, announced in last October that it planned to provide fractional CFD trading, which allows investors to purchase a portion of a CFD contract, enabling more investors with limited funds to access CFDs. Then, the London-based FX & CFD broker INFINOX added 560 new stock CFDs in the same month. Broker BidX Markets also expanded its CFD offerings into the crypto sector. In December, Admirals added 300 CFDs for US stocks, including well-known brands like Roku, DoorDash, and Data Dog. All of these stocks can be traded on the broker's MT5 platform.

At the start of 2023, the European CFD broker FIBO Group planned to extend its business to LATAM. Similarly, FXOpen introduced commission-free index CFD trading in early January. In addition, platforms like VT Markets and Dukascopy have just recently broadened their CFD offerings.

The Rise of CFD: An Answer to the Investors' Growing Demand for Greater Flexibility and Diversified Investment Options

Generally, trading in financial markets can be categorized into two main types: cash / spot and derivatives. Spot trading, of course, is the good o' "cash for delivery" fashion. On the other hand, derivatives trading is much more complex, where the value of instruments is derived from underlying assets, such as securities, futures, currencies, cryptos, precious metals, and commodities.

As a financial derivative itself, CFD trading is attractive due to its high-risk, high-return leverage, and the ability to achieve portfolio diversification through multiple trading instruments. CFDs are essentially contracts between buyers and sellers speculating on the future price fluctuations of underlying assets, allowing investors to engage in margin trading with only a small amount of capital.

Therefore, CFDs are similar to futures, swaps, and options, allowing investors to speculate on asset values without actually having to deal with delivery. On the other hand, the potential for leveraged high returns also attracts many speculators. Especially with the increasing popularity of online trading, CFDs as a type of OTC do not need to go through exchanges, which naturally make them more attractive to "stay-at-home traders" in this post-Covid world. This is also one of the reasons why more and more brokers are starting to step into the CFD brokerage business.

CFD-Related Scams and Risks Can Go Both Ways

However, CFD trading is fraught with scams and risks that can go both ways. While scams aimed at traders are typically the ones exposed over media, brokers can also fall prey to such dangers. In last October, the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) stopped the operations of 16 CFD brokers in the kingdom. Then in December, FCA again issued a warning to CFD platforms, urging them to sell their instruments in a more reasonable manner.

For traders, the dangers of CFD trading primarily stem from fraudulent trading platforms, invalid trading signals, malicious manipulation of markets, Ponzi schemes, so-called "bonus", and custody trading, among other things. However, many of these hazards pose an equal threat to brokers.

For instance, in 2015, the UK office of Alpari FX went bankrupt because the debts the broker owed clients exceeded the funds they had. The broker claimed that its bankruptcy was mainly due to the Swiss National Bank's announcement on January 15 of that year to cancel its bottom support policy for the EUR/CHF rate, which caused the Swiss franc rate to skyrocket, resulting in significant debt. However, it was later unveiled that some trades were executed by fraudsters who submitted orders to the broker using forged identity and sold large amounts of EUR/CHF positions when the price soared, earning them massive profits. When the broker realized the scheme, they were unable to bear the losses, ultimately leading to the bankruptcy.

Similarly, in 2019, NAGA the broker stated that some clients traded illegally and manipulated market prices, causing significant losses on the broker.

In 2020, Australian broker ACM FX was accused of paying a large commission to an illegal trading company in Mexico in exchange for fake orders provided in return. These orders caused losses to ACM FX's clients, while the illegal Mexico company reaped the benefits. ACM FX later stated that they did not know these orders were forged.

Strategies for Brokers to Follow

To survive and thrive, brokers must take a range of measures to safeguard both themselves and traders. Critical areas of focus include creating prudent trading rules, prioritizing KYC compliance, providing adequate investment education to traders, scrutinizing and monitoring partnerships (including providers of payment, tech, and liquidity), and regularly monitoring clients' trading activities and market fluctuations.

The establishment of prudent trading rules is a pivotal first step. Brokers must set margin and leverage ratios that are commensurate with market conditions and risk levels to manage traders' risks, avoid unnecessary losses, and protect their own interests. For instance, while advertising a 1:500 leverage for forex CFD trading, the broker may still require traders to bear a sufficiently high margin to ensure safety. By setting a reasonable leverage and margin ratio, the broker can ensure the best interests of both parties are served.

Bottom Line

In conclusion, offering CFD trading as a broker is a delicate enterprise that must be approached with caution. To maximize the benefits for both traders and brokers, it is crucial to establish effective risk management and stop-loss strategies, formulate reasonable trading rules, and provide ample education and training to traders. By taking these actions, brokers can effectively avoid falling prey to CFD trading scams and foster a safer and more sustainable trading environment for all.